Logo

Talented but won’t listen: What should a manager do before losing a top performer?

Your sous chef is the most skilled cook in the kitchen. Your shift leader is the one regulars ask for by name. Yet every time you introduce a new procedure, they nod and carry on the old way. For many hospitality managers, the "talented but won't listen" employee is harder to handle than a weak one: you cannot afford to lose them, and you cannot let them break the standard.

Talented but won’t listen: What should a manager do before losing a top performer?

Why top performers are often the hardest to lead

Quản lý trao đổi riêng với nhân viên

Trao đổi riêng, hỏi trước khi nói · Ảnh: Amy Hirschi / Unsplash

Gallup's State of the Global Workplace 2025 report found global employee engagement fell to 21% in 2024, while manager engagement itself dropped from 30% to 27%. Gallup has long shown that the direct manager shapes most of a team's engagement. So when a strong performer "won't listen", the first question is not "what is wrong with them?" but "what is missing in the management relationship?". Typical reasons: they believe their way works better; they were not consulted; they doubt the manager's expertise; expectations are vague; and there are no consequences either way.

Five steps to be heard without losing your best people

Đội ngũ bếp

Giao vai trò hướng dẫn cho người giỏi · Ảnh: Trường Trung Cấp Kinh Tế Du Lịch TP.HCM (CET) / Unsplash

  1. Separate results from methods. Hold firm on outcomes and non-negotiables (portioning, food safety, check-in, cash handling); allow flexibility elsewhere.
  2. Ask before you tell. Ten minutes asking "What in this procedure won't work on the floor?" turns a critic into a co-owner.
  3. Use data, not job titles. Remakes, ticket times, guest ratings and waste move the conversation from "who is right" to "how do we improve".
  4. Put expectations in writing. A one-page SOP with 5–7 checkpoints beats ten verbal reminders.
  5. Give a role, not just orders. Ask them to train new hires or pilot new procedures; teaching a standard makes people own it.

When to have the direct conversation

If the employee still deliberately breaks non-negotiables after explanation and support, hold a private, specific conversation: describe the behaviour, its impact, the expectation, the deadline and the consequence, and document it according to company HR procedures. Silence tells the whole team that talent buys exceptions.

Conclusion

Strong performers do not need a manager who is better at everything. They need one who is clear about standards, asks good questions, uses data and speaks directly when needed. These are learnable skills, at the core of the hospitality management development programmes IRR delivers with its partners.


Source: Gallup, State of the Global Workplace 2025 Report.

IRR Group – International Recreation & Resort Management

Support

Support

Telephone: 0909.140.866

Email: info@irrmanagement.com.vn